data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/e2dca/e2dcaef68768804d959c96efe4cedb2b68fb9fb8" alt=""
Score: 8.4
You have to admire the do it yourself attitude these guys have, if nothing else. They wrote, produced, and printed this album all with their own abilities and (I'm sure) monies. The naivety of thinking that says an internet band can start off in MySpace and wind up on a major label infects this album, and is the one principle reason why they actually did start off on MySpace and wind up on a major label. Enthusiasm, a child-like, viral enthusiasm, is found on every track and every note of this album, and the entire attraction of this CD on a listener is wound up on it.
And let's be glad too, because as far as ingenuity goes, this album doesn't really have it in spades. That's not to say anything bad, but this is the same basic sound as can be found in most indie-synth-pop-rock bands out there. A bit of Bowie, a few indie classics, and a sprinkling of the Cure throughout cures this sound to perfection, and on Clap Your Hands Say Yeah, the sound is crystal clear and still as infectious as it was the first time some hipsters got together and decided to make music. For more recent reference, this band is eerily similar at times to the Wolf Parade, though at moments it borrows more from the Arcade Fire, and of course name-cousins the Yeah Yeah Yeahs. No real comparison can be made however, because there is one unique thing about this band that will likely keep it fresh for the next few years, and that is the voice of Alec Ounsworth, whose ecstatic, yelping, completely indecipherable voice is the head steering mechanism on this album. When the band is at its best, the music follows closely, gently guiding the wheel and intoning its own direction as well. At its worst... well, there really isn't a worst. That's because this album is maddeningly consistent.
Except from the standouts in the middle, "Details of the War" and "The Skin Of My Yellow Country Teeth", the album never really pulls you beyond the stratosphere as you feel it could. It rather holds you quite aloft, tossing you gently this way and that. A fun ride, but not one as memorable as others you might go on, a fact which is only highlighted by the two middle tracks undeniable quality, which makes the rest pale (somewhat) in comparison. It also lacks the genuine ballad or even more general pace and sound changes that can keep an album running after its legs have started to burn. On nearly every song, there is a steady, driving, up-tempo rhythm on the drums, a nice, faint synth-loop that fades as soon as the vocals hit, and a simple guitar riff that places well alongside the rest.
It's only the stripped down and eerily sentimental "Details of the War" that provides anything resembling a change of direction. It provides that well however, as the lack of guitar really gives Ounsworth enough space to let his strangely emotion-filled harmony burn its way into your ears. And who knew a harmonica could provide so much sensation? Though sparsely used, it fits perfectly and is probably the highlight of the album, as the song speeds up into nowhere after that, and the CD never really resurrects itself to that sensation of catharsis. "The Skin Of My Yellow Teeth" manages to pick up at that same up-tempo rhythm, but once again its all guitar and jangly drums, although set with a melody that is so catchy you won't help but return to it again and again.
The rest of this album makes this a ridiculously easy review to write, and though I am not as enamored as other critics have been with this album, it's definitely of a high quality. The key question of whether CYHSY capitalizes on the entire indie-guitar sound as well as those other bands mentioned above is kind of uncertain. For me, they don't, mostly because they seem afraid to innovate or go beyond what they knew would work and work well. I can't really punish them for that, and I doubt I will be skipping over too many of this albums' tracks as they come up on my iTunes; but for the moment, I don't think I'll be searching them out too often either.